Search
Close this search box.

June 5, 2024

ICAS Bulletin (online ISSN 2836-3418, print ISSN 2836-340X) is published every other week throughout the year at 1919 M St NW, Suite 310, Washington, DC 20036.
The online version of ICAS Bulletin can be found at chinaus-icas.org/bulletins/.

- What's Going On? -

U.S. and China Top-Level Military Officials Meet at Shangri-La Dialogue

Secretary of Defense Lloyd J. Austin III delivers plenary remarks at the International Institute for Strategic Studies 21th Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore, June 1, 2024. (Source: Department of Defense, Public Domain)

– On May 31, on the sidelines of the Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore, U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin and Chinese Defense Minister Dong Jun held the first high-level, in-person, bilateral meeting since U.S.-China military dialogues broke down in 2022. Both sides agreed to continue regular military-to-military communications.
– A day after the U.S. and Chinese military officials met, Secretary Austin delivered plenary remarks to the Dialogue in which he stressed the importance of a renewed U.S.-China dialogue, claiming that war with China is “neither imminent nor unavoidable.”
– Secretary Austin further stated in his remarks that the U.S. commitment to the Philippines is “ironclad.” In response, the Chinese delegation accused the U.S. of seeking to build an Asia-Pacific version of the NATO security alliance.
– One day following Secretary Austin’s speech, Chinese Defense Minister Dong Jun, in his own remarks at the Shangri-La Dialogue, accused the U.S. of destabilizing the Asia-Pacific region through its support for the Philippines and Taiwan.
– At a sideline interview in Singapore, U.S. National Security Agency Director Timothy Haugh stated that China has developed hacking technologies that are “prepositioned” to attack critical infrastructure.

U.S.-China Tensions Aided by Some Reassuring Connections

A panda at the Smithsonian’s National Zoo. (Credit: Photo by Mehgan Murphy via Smithsonian’s National Zoo, Public Domain)

– On May 30, U.S. Deputy Secretary of State Kurt Campbell met China’s Vice Foreign Minister Ma Zhouxu in Washington D.C. to discuss issues surrounding Taiwan, the war in Ukraine, and the nuclearization of North Korea. A State Department spokesperson explained that the meeting with Minister Ma was a part of the United States’ continued diplomatic effort to increase U.S.-China senior-level engagement.
– The Smithsonian’s National Zoo announced on May 29 that two giant pandas, who China considers as ‘envoys of friendship,’ will arrive in Washington D.C. by the end of 2024. The announcement came as a warmly received surprise after the lease agreements on three giant pandas at the Smithsonian Zoo expired in late 2023 without renewal.
– On May 28, following bilateral consultations on maritime affairs, the Chinese Foreign Ministry announced that the U.S. and China have agreed to maintain continued dialogue over maritime affairs to manage risks and avoid misunderstandings.
– The number of American students visiting China has notably begun to increase, reaching approximately 800 as American universities initiate new initiatives for exchanges in China.

Washington Increases Pressure on Beijing Over Trade With Russia

(Source: Getty Images, Royalty-Free)

– On May 31, U.S. Deputy Treasury Secretary Wally Adeyemo publicly threatened to impose export controls and sanctions on Chinese firms in response to China’s trade relationship with Russia.
– During a visit to Brussels on May 29, U.S. Deputy Secretary of State Kurt Campbell called upon European nations to harden their positions on Beijing for its aid to Russia and to protect European security interests.
– After the British Defense Secretary Grant Shapps accused China of supporting Russia with combat equipment in the Ukrainian war, Biden’s National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan challenged this claim, saying that “we have not seen that to date.”
– Beijing imposed retaliatory sanctions on 12 U.S. defense-related companies and 10 company executives in response to the United States’ “illegal unilateral sanctions” on Chinese companies that are suspected to have ties with Russia.

The Private Sector Strives to Navigate Sour U.S.-China Relations

(Source: Getty Images)

– U.S. economist and former chairman of Morgan Stanley Asia Stephen Roach, speaking during a public event in Beijing, said U.S. trade policies against China are risking an endless ‘trade war’ between the two nations.
– The U.S. Commerce Department has slowed the process of issuing licenses to Nvidia and Advanced Micro Devices for advanced AI chip exports to Middle Eastern countries given concerns over potential Chinese acquisition.
– Chinese firms, such as Wanxiang America Corp. which supply car components, face an increasingly difficult business environment in the United States as anti-China sentiment and concerns of national security continue to block business deals.
– In response to ongoing blocks and restrictions, many U.S.-blacklisted Chinese companies, including Huawei, Hesai Group, rebrand themselves by setting up American affiliates or subsidiaries to dodge U.S. regulations.
– JPMorgan Asia Pacific CEO Sjoerd Leenart warned that China cannot be sidelined in the global economy given its rise as a second world power. He stated that businesses and investors “have to do business there.”

The U.S. Again Places Diplomatic Attention on Taiwan

President Lai Ching-te presents U.S. House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Michael McCaul with a gift during a visit to Taipei on May 27. (Source: Office of the President, ROC, Public Domain)

– Shortly after China’s two-day military exercise surrounding Taiwan, Washington appointed Raymond Greene, a veteran diplomat, as the new U.S. representative in Taiwan. He is set to start his position at the American Institute of Taiwan in the summer of 2024.
– Despite Beijing’s vocal opposition, U.S. House Representative Michael McCaul led a bipartisan congressional delegation to visit Taiwan’s newly inaugurated president, Lai Tsing-Te, days after his inauguration during which he expressed U.S. support for Taiwan.
– During the delegation visit, Representative McCaul reiterated the United States’ commitment to strengthen Taiwan’s defense capability against Chinese military aggression, also promising to accelerate U.S. weapon delivery to Taiwan.
– Two days after Representative McCaul’s visit, a second U.S. delegation, led by Senator Tammy Duckworth, met with President Lai in Taipei. Senator Duckworth told President Lai that “you can count on us to always show up for Taiwan.”
– The U.S. State Department expressed concerns over China’s two-day military exercise surrounding Taiwan in reaction to Lai’s inauguration speech and urged Beijing to act with restraint.

In Other News

(Credit: Photo by Albert Canite via Unsplash)

“US Defense Secretary discusses military exchanges in visit to China ally Cambodia,” Reuters, June 4
“US and Its Partners Stand Together as China Exports Problems, Rahm Emanuel Says,” Bloomberg, June 4 [Paywall]
“Biden’s science adviser explains the new hard line on China,” The Washington Post, June 3 [Paywall]
“Chinese Businesses target Vietnam and Mexico as trade tensions with US rise,” Financial Times, June 3 [Paywall]
“Chinese Firms Jostle With US Peers for Sliver of Gulf Oil Riches,” Bloomberg, June 3 [Paywall]
“China lands probe on moon’s far side to gather rocks and soil in growing space rivalry with U.S.,” PBS, June 2
“The CEO Trying to Smooth U.S.-China Tensions in Farm Country,” The Wall Street Journal, June 2 [Paywall] 
“In a first, OpenAI removes influence operations tied to Russia, China and Israel,” NPR, May 31
“TikTok Pauses E-Commerce Push into Europe to Focus on US,” Bloomberg, May 31 [Paywall]
“US Cyber Chief Sees ‘Very Aggressive’ Chinese Hacking Strategy,” Bloomberg, May 31[Paywall]
“Exodus of US law firms from Shanghai accelerates,” Financial Times, May 30 [Paywall]
“Expulsions of Chinese Students Spread Confusion From Yale to UVA,” Bloomberg, May 29 [Paywall]
“University of Florida employee, students implicated in illegal plot to ship drugs, toxins to China,” AP, May 28
“US sanctions Chinese individuals over COVID-related fraud, bomb threats,” Reuters, May 28
“Xi Hosts Arab Leaders as China’s ‘Soft Power’ Expands in Mideast,” Bloomberg, May 28 [Paywall]
“China premier agrees on cooperation with Seoul, Tokyo but issues veiled rebuke against their US ties,” AP, May 27
“Taiwan president calls on US lawmakers for help to strengthen defences,” Financial Times, May 27 [Paywall]
“Pentagon chief seeks to woo Cambodia from China with Phnom Penh visit,” Financial Times, May 24 [Paywall]
“TikTok says it removed an influence campaign originating in China,” The Washington Post, May 23 [Paywall]
“Fraud Trial Begins for Chinese Billionaire Who Allied Himself With America’s Right,” The New York Times, May 22 [Paywall]
“House Panel Seeks F.B.I. Investigation Into Doping by Chinese Swimmers,” The New York Times, May 22 [Paywall]
“Inter Milan Seized by Oaktree After Chinese Owner Defaults on Debt,” Bloomberg, May 22 [Paywall]

- What Are We Reading? -

- What's Happening Around Town? -

- What ICAS Is Up To -

Upcoming TnT Event

U.S.-China and Trade Frictions: How Much Worse Will It Get?
Thursday, June 13, 2024
9:00am – 10:00am EDT

Aggravated trade tensions are once again rising to the fore in U.S-China relations. In mid-May, President Biden confirmed the Trump administration’s Section 301 tariffs on China and proceeded to heap additional tariff raises on semiconductors, EVs, batteries, and solar cells. In late-May, Treasury Secretary Yellen sounded the alarm on Chinese ‘overcapacity’, calling it a “threat to the development of clean energy industries around the world”. The recent G7 Finance Ministers statement vows to “ensure a level playing field, in line with WTO principles” to counter China’s “comprehensive use of non-market policies and practices”. China strenuously denies these charges, pointing to its competitive edge in many clean energy industries. How will it respond to the U.S.’ tariff measures? Will it continue to maintain a low-key approach?

Later this June, Trump and Biden will square off in their first presidential debate, vowing to be tougher than the other in responding to the ‘Second China Shock’. What is the outlook for U.S. trade policy in the months and years ahead? Is protectionism here to stay? How are U.S.-China trade and industrial policy tensions expected to play out during this election year? Across the Atlantic, the European Commission is priming its trade defense instruments against Chinese EV imports. Will it also use its Foreign Subsidies Regulation rulebook to push back against the likely torrent of Chinese greenfield EV investment that has begun to wash up on the EU’s shores? Is there a difference in approach between the U.S. and the EU in dealing with the ‘Second China Shock’? China has initiated WTO dispute settlement proceedings against the Inflation Reduction Act’s trade-distorting EV subsidies. What is the outlook for third-party dispute settlement and for the multilateral trade system, more broadly, particularly as the U.S. reverts to its pre-WTO era usage of its Section 301 instrument? To listen to these pressing bilateral and multilateral trade and tariff-related questions, tune in to the ICAS Trade ‘n Technology Program event on June 13.

MAP Issue Brief

Big Wave and Undercurrent:
Washington’s Duo-Track Efforts to Compete with China in the Global Maritime Influence
By Yilun Zhang, Amanda Jin
May 23, 2024

Key Takeaways:

  • Washington’s efforts to strengthen U.S. shipbuilding and the U.S. shipping industry derived not only from economic and trade concerns, but also from essential needs under the strategic competition. The industrial capacity of shipbuilding and influence in the global maritime logistics industry represent two cornerstones of leadership in the international maritime domain as the United States seeks to secure its control of the sea against a rapidly rising China.
  • Although the U.S. commercial shipbuilding industry has been in general decline since the Second World War, the impact of the shipbuilding capability decline on U.S. naval power was not felt until recently, when the U.S. Navy struggled to keep up with China’s pace in terms of producing more capable warships. Under the strategic competition, it is imminent for the U.S. to strengthen its shipbuilding capacity even if it is against economic common sense.
U.S. President Joe Biden at the Philadelphia Shipyard, accompanied by CEO Steinar Nerbovik, Great Lakes Dredge and Dock CEO Lasse Johannes Petterson, and workers Don King and Vern Smith, Thursday, July 20, 2023. (Official White House Photo by Adam Schultz
  • After realizing that the gravity of global shipping and supply chains moved to Asia and mainland China, U.S. policymakers made a multitude of efforts to strengthen the U.S. shipping industry to secure U.S. export interests and ensure U.S. influence over global shipping, maritime connectivity and trade. Nevertheless, the U.S. shipping industry still lagged behind significantly in key industrial upgrades and could need exceptional policy support.
  • Among the Biden administration’s effort to enhance U.S. shipping competitiveness, U.S. agencies made several efforts to enhance its grasp over global shipping regulation, especially by eliminating barriers between law enforcement teams and civil regulators. This criminal-civil fusion has enabled criminal law enforcement to benefit from the monitoring power, industrial expertise and investigative capability of civil regulators

Commentary

A Landmark Advisory Opinion: ITLOS Strengthens Legal Framework for Climate Action
By Nong Hong
May 28, 2024

On May 21, 2024, the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (ITLOS) issued a groundbreaking Advisory Opinion on climate change, which marks a historic first – an international legal body directly addressing state obligations for mitigating climate change, a critical step forward in holding nations accountable for their actions.

The request made to ITLOS in December 2022 by the Commission of Small Island States on Climate Change and International Law seeks clarification on states’ obligations under UNCLOS regarding the prevention, reduction, and control of marine pollution, as well as the protection and preservation of the marine environment in relation to climate change impacts. This is the first time an advisory opinion has been sought on issues specifically related to sea-level rise and climate change more broadly.

ICAS In the News

On Monday, May 27, 2024, Senior Fellow Sourabh Gupta discussed the trilateral summit between China, South Korea, and Japan on CGTN.

  • “The important point to note is that the trilateral summit is fundamentally, first and foremost, an economic and trade gathering [between China, South Korea, and Japan].”
  • “[The three countries] trade a lot with each other, and yet, this is the one part of the world where they do not have a real free trade agreement with each other.”
Senior Fellow Sourabh Gupta appearing on CGTN on May 27, 2024

On Wednesday, May 22, 2024, Senior Fellow Sourabh Gupta was quoted by China Daily on the first U.S-China talks on AI in Geneva.

  • There was a genuine sense of “constructiveness” at the AI meeting, “given that it opened a channel for communication on an issue that will require a degree of cooperation and coordination from both sides for a long time and given its importance”.
  • “There’s value in all the big players in the system coming and proposing common rules by which AI is regulated at the international level. And so that’s also a useful area of dialogue within the framework of this conversation.”